Can sumo deads be a replacement for deadlifts?

  1. Can sumo deads be a replacement for deadlifts?


    After reading about sumo deadlifts and them being easier for taller people, I am considering trying them. I wanted to know however would it be more beneficial to learn how to do a standard deadlift better, or could I just switch to sumos? When I do my standard deadlifts, my arms always hit my knees, causing them to go inward alittle. If I try to have a wider grip so this doesn't happen, it sort of feels like I'm putting my wrists in a bad position, because I have to grip real wide for this not to happen. I'm 6' and I have just under a 6' 4" wingspan. With ddeadlifts, I'm less worried about size and more worried about strength. My legs are huge as it is and they grow with little effort. As long as I get strong enough to where I can lift people up, I'll be happy lol.


  2. If it's to get the strongest pull you can, then yes. However, the technique is MUCH more difficult.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  3. I find that I like a wide stance when I squat and even when I deadlift it feels better to have my stance wider than a normal stance, never did a sumo dead lift stance, but I kind of do something inbetween. If I narrow my stance it doesn't feel right and it's harder to activate my glutes with a narrow stance.
    •   
       


  4. I get alittle bit of lower back strain. It's not bad, but after about 2 reps it becomes a pain. As I stated as long as it can simulate me picking someone up and by making my lower body stronger, it'll make it so I can push my upper body more, I definitely may start doing sumos. Would I have to start with a lower weight on sumos though? Come to think of it when I pick things up off the ground I already use a sumo stance, I just never really noticed.

  5. Quote Originally Posted by DerickVonD View Post
    I get alittle bit of lower back strain. It's not bad, but after about 2 reps it becomes a pain. As I stated as long as it can simulate me picking someone up and by making my lower body stronger, it'll make it so I can push my upper body more, I definitely may start doing sumos. Would I have to start with a lower weight on sumos though? Come to think of it when I pick things up off the ground I already use a sumo stance, I just never really noticed.
    If you get strain that easily, then you need to correct the imbalances in your hips and core.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  6. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja View Post
    If you get strain that easily, then you need to correct the imbalances in your hips and core.
    Any suggestions?

  7. Quote Originally Posted by DerickVonD View Post
    Any suggestions?
    Can't make suggestions without pics of posture, training breakdown, footwear, etc.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  8. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja View Post
    Can't make suggestions without pics of posture, training breakdown, footwear, etc.
    Well I'm too broke to get a new camera right now, but I am flat footed and when I train I wear Asics Gel-Evolution 6. Do you know any general stretches that would help? Basically my problem is I can lift the weight up, but after the first rep I start to feel minor strain. The first rep feels perfect, but the reps that fellow feel alittle off. I do two set of 3-5 reps with a 2-3 minute rest between sets.

  9. You're wearing the wrong shoes. Get flat-soled shoes for lifting (e.g. Chuck's).
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  10. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja View Post
    You're wearing the wrong shoes. Get flat-soled shoes for lifting (e.g. Chuck's).
    They hurt my feet, I workout at home so I could go barefoot, but I am afraid I over pronate, less than I did before but it feels easier to go lower with the shoes than without.

  11. This seems like it would work great for me. This looks sort of like a hybrid between the two http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9BTQe...ure=plpp_video

  12. Quote Originally Posted by DerickVonD View Post
    They hurt my feet, I workout at home so I could go barefoot, but I am afraid I over pronate, less than I did before but it feels easier to go lower with the shoes than without.
    Suck it up.

    Quote Originally Posted by DerickVonD View Post
    This seems like it would work great for me. This looks sort of like a hybrid between the two http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9BTQe...ure=plpp_video
    Awful advice from that guy (as usual). You're not that tall and having long arms makes you ideal for sumo. Look at Dave Tate's instructionals and ignore everything from Hulse.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  13. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja View Post
    Suck it up.



    Awful advice from that guy (as usual). You're not that tall and having long arms makes you ideal for sumo. Look at Dave Tate's instructionals and ignore everything from Hulse.
    Wait so you're saying I should try sumos than? Also what about my knees hitting my arms? The reason I wear shoes when I lift is so I don't over pronate and put pressure on my knees and low back.

  14. Dave talks about a medium stance deadlift in this http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cr2_mCh2dUI
    However it's hard to see the technique because the video quality is ****.

  15. Quote Originally Posted by DerickVonD View Post
    Wait so you're saying I should try sumos than? Also what about my knees hitting my arms? The reason I wear shoes when I lift is so I don't over pronate and put pressure on my knees and low back.
    If your setup is correct, you won't hit your knees. Wear Chuck's not running shoes when you train lower body. They're what's causing you to shift the weight onto your toes and strain your lumbar.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  16. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja View Post
    If your setup is correct, you won't hit your knees. Wear Chuck's not running shoes when you train lower body. They're what's causing you to shift the weight onto your toes and strain your lumbar.
    In that case, I rather just train barefoot. I train at home on a carpeted floor. I wore hard sole shoes before for walking and everything and my knees started to hurt bad, I wasn't training at all at the time.

  17. Quote Originally Posted by DerickVonD View Post
    In that case, I rather just train barefoot. I train at home on a carpeted floor. I wore hard sole shoes before for walking and everything and my knees started to hurt bad, I wasn't training at all at the time.

    Just wear the Chucks while training, not for walking/running/anything else. I use them, hate the way they feel when walking, but they are great for squats and deadlifts.

  18. Quote Originally Posted by boogyman View Post
    Just wear the Chucks while training, not for walking/running/anything else. I use them, hate the way they feel when walking, but they are great for squats and deadlifts.
    Another issue is I'm broke atleast for the rest the month.

  19. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja
    If it's to get the strongest pull you can, then yes. However, the technique is MUCH more difficult.
    Hell yeah...

    What's these bloody knees I keep hearing about?
    Hardcore Purus Labs {Rep}
    Lift the fücking weight from the floor, or leave it on the ground. The thoughts are supposed to be daunting. The pain is meant to be tormenting.

  20. Quote Originally Posted by AaronJP1 View Post
    Hell yeah...

    What's these bloody knees I keep hearing about?
    my shins look like they've been through a meat grinder...

  21. Any videos of you dead lifting?

  22. Quote Originally Posted by AaronJP1 View Post
    Hell yeah...

    What's these bloody knees I keep hearing about?
    His setup is bad if his knees are getting scraped. At most, I could see shins from the bar or maybe taking out some of the quad with one of the hands, but not bloody knees.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  23. Quote Originally Posted by Frank Reynolds View Post
    Any videos of you dead lifting?
    No I'd need a friend to take a video of me and that might be awhile, sicne none of my friends live close.

  24. Due to you not owning a camera/smart phone?

  25. Quote Originally Posted by Frank Reynolds View Post
    Due to you not owning a camera/smart phone?
    Well I do own a camera but its real real ****ty quality on video. I'm out of batteries and I have a damn blackberry phone.

  26. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja
    You're wearing the wrong shoes. Get flat-soled shoes for lifting (e.g. Chuck's).
    ^^^ this. I switched to flat-soled bare-boned canvas shoes (Puma). They feel great for deads. BTW I am 6 foot 4 plus and use a standard Deadlift stance.

  27. I would say to just take the time to learn Sumo and get as much info as possible. Ironically how different we all are because i am 6' 4" and conventional deads are my favorite lift. Best Romanian Deadlift was 315 x 20, 365 x 8. Never have tried sumo myself but maybe i should look into it

    And i believe i read you don't want your legs growing? Sumo deads are a LOT more leg dominant for most people but you will probably be very strong on them too.
    I hope everybody thinks i'm crazy, because you cannot be a sane person and go through the type of pain i am willing to put myself through to be where i want to be, Once I completely win the war between my mind and body, my reign will begin. ~Me

  28. Quote Originally Posted by Rodja

    His setup is bad if his knees are getting scraped. At most, I could see shins from the bar or maybe taking out some of the quad with one of the hands, but not bloody knees.
    Quote Originally Posted by napalm

    my shins look like they've been through a meat grinder...
    I can dig it.
    Hardcore Purus Labs {Rep}
    Lift the fücking weight from the floor, or leave it on the ground. The thoughts are supposed to be daunting. The pain is meant to be tormenting.

  29. Quote Originally Posted by thetinyguy View Post
    I would say to just take the time to learn Sumo and get as much info as possible. Ironically how different we all are because i am 6' 4" and conventional deads are my favorite lift. Best Romanian Deadlift was 315 x 20, 365 x 8. Never have tried sumo myself but maybe i should look into it

    And i believe i read you don't want your legs growing? Sumo deads are a LOT more leg dominant for most people but you will probably be very strong on them too.
    Sumos are generally not for the taller population. The leverage is just not there since you can't go wide enough to really get the fully sumo technique. However, they are hip dominant and not so much thigh dominant.
    M.Ed. Ex Phys


  30. Quote Originally Posted by thetinyguy View Post
    I would say to just take the time to learn Sumo and get as much info as possible. Ironically how different we all are because i am 6' 4" and conventional deads are my favorite lift. Best Romanian Deadlift was 315 x 20, 365 x 8. Never have tried sumo myself but maybe i should look into it

    And i believe i read you don't want your legs growing? Sumo deads are a LOT more leg dominant for most people but you will probably be very strong on them too.
    It's not that I don't want my legs to grow, it's just with legs I'm more concerned with strength and not size as much, since my legs are already massive granted some of that is fat.
  

  
 

Similar Forum Threads

  1. Replies: 2
    Last Post: 12-01-2009, 02:03 PM
  2. Can I be on Resveratrol for ever
    By buster0371 in forum Supplements
    Replies: 36
    Last Post: 08-22-2009, 05:28 PM
  3. Replies: 7
    Last Post: 07-16-2008, 03:31 PM
  4. Replies: 1
    Last Post: 05-11-2008, 01:27 PM
  5. Replies: 10
    Last Post: 10-19-2005, 03:44 AM
Log in
Log in