Wow! How does a guy who is coaching for a long time have to establish credibility? Scott is genuine. Go ahead and disagree or point out of fact that may be off, but to call him out like that? I mean hang on one comment? So many internet coaches have stolen or repackaged his ideas and training methods. I'd say that is credibility right there. Goodness.
I don't know why you're taking it so personal and defending him so much. He is probably great coach because of his personal experience.
But I'm not sure what is magical or special about him. If your diet in check, and have solid training program, then you will make the gains. Solid nutritionist with solid BB background would probably optimize your results and see enough change in a year than you would from any training program alone in 5 years.
For me, and it is a personal opinion, he lost credibility and here is why:
1. If he fabricates stories or facts to prove his point, then how would I assume his point is valid? other than having pure faith in him?
2. He presents research as if it is conclusive evidence, however he just mentions research was done but doesn't even analyze the research. If you do follow the research he cited you will find trumendous gaps as well as contradicting results. But taking him at face value makes his technique looks science backed (textbook marketing credibility building technique)
3. He is not presenting new ideas. He is repackaging some of the pre-existing practices and writing about it in such conviction. He is not alone in his stance, and there are other counter stances as well. If you want to consider his training as the golden standard then so be it. But you would be discounting the teachings of other greater BBers, Mentzer for example or strenght trainers such as Bill Starr and the list goes on and on.
4. I can smell the marketing techniques tought by Dan Kennedy and other marketing gurus from 10 miles away. Establish yourself as an expert by explaining what you know, knowing that what you know is more than the average person, even if by a bit. Establish a "cult" of followers who will believe everything you say and buy anything you will sell (There is a book also on how to do it, I would need to look it up).
I know because I have studied all Dan Kennedy's material and teachings. He is following it to the "T" except the fabrication of facts and science to prove a point of view. Feel free to join Bill Myers' website to learn how to establish yourself as a guru online to sell products, it is $10/month membership and you will see the exact same pattern.
If you want to follow his method, go for it. I didn't say he sucks as a coach, I said for me he lost credibility to read what he has to say or invest in his material he is selling.
If you're diet is in check, and you train within the rep range that produce hypertrophy then you will see results. You can credit him for it too. I am 100% sure he still does max or near max load within the standard rep range used by the majority. He seem to be old school BBer.
Again, don't take it personally. I've just saw the pattern I am accustomed to and noticed the blatant discrepencies for me not to buy into him that is all.