Sherdog P4P Rankings 1/9/08
01-09-2008 01:10 PM
Sherdog P4P Rankings 1/9/08
January 9, 2008
The first Sherdog pound-for-pound rankings in 2008 deliver a significant shakeup outside the top three.
Jumping onto the list is Georges St. Pierre (Pictures), who goes from unranked into the top five. Also joining the list for the first time is featherweight Urijah Faber (Pictures), who defended his WEC belt in December against Jeff Curran (Pictures).
Lightweights Gilbert Melendez (Pictures), loser of a tight decision on New Year's Eve, and Sean Sherk (Pictures), inactive while fighting and serving a suspension for steroids, were dropped from the list.
1) Anderson Silva (20-4)
After a career of appearing on pound-for-pound lists before being unceremoniously evacuated, Silva has put together the most impressive streak of his career during a period of monumental upset and inactivity. The only blemish on Silva's record in his last nine fights is his infamous disqualification loss to Yushin Okami (Pictures), but that doesn't prevent the 32 year old from to taking the top spot. Beyond that mishap, he's steamrolled his competition. Moreover, three of his last four wins have come against firmly entrenched, high-standing top-10 fighters. The toughest test of Silva's UFC middleweight reign will come in March when the Brazilian faces the last man to hold the PRIDE 183-pound title, Dan Henderson (Pictures).
2) Quinton Jackson (Pictures) (29-6)
Let there be no mistake, there is certainly a case for putting "Rampage" atop this list. Jackson, alongside Silva, seems to be the only top fighter beating other top fighters in a stretch of upsets and inactivity. His back-to-back wins over Chuck Liddell (Pictures) and Dan Henderson (Pictures) are certainly sterling. However, "Rampage" has the potential to strengthen his pound-for-pound status more than any other fighter because a steady crop of elite light heavyweights appear to be coming down the pipeline for him. Having nursed an injured hand, the 28-year-old Jackson returns to the limelight when he acts as coach on season seven of "The Ultimate Fighter," after which he'll defend his UFC light heavyweight belt against Forrest Griffin (Pictures).
3) Fedor Emelianenko (Pictures) (27-1, 1 NC)
Mixed martial arts' most enduring pound-for-pound figure remains in the third spot. Nothing's changed for "The Last Emperor," except for the only real crucial aspect to this list: fighting solid competition. While Emelianenko's second win over Nogueira and his triumph over "Cro Cop" are not ancient history, his only remotely meritorious heavyweight victory in the last two years was over Mark Hunt (Pictures). A New Year's Eve submission victory over Hong Man Choi (Pictures) did nothing to deter detractors who claim Fedor's status is based on less than stellar competition. The 31-year-old Russian heavyweight king must get back to fighting competitive bouts, otherwise he could squander all that he worked for over the years.
4) Georges St. Pierre (Pictures) (15-2)
Absent from these rankings due to his stunning loss last April to Matt Serra (Pictures), the 26-year-old French-Canadian jumps into the fourth spot due to his impressive submission over Matt Hughes (Pictures) and the fact that he basically cleaned out the welterweight division over the past two years. If he can avenge his loss to Serra this coming April in his home city of Montreal, St. Pierre -- the No. 1 ranked welterweight -- St. Pierre could be considered the most dominant fighter in MMA. If he defeats Serra, a fight with Jon Fitch (Pictures) could materialize in the latter half of 2008.
5) Dan Henderson (Pictures) (22-6)
One of the most recognizable fighters with dual-divisional clout, the 37-year-old former Olympian had repeatedly told Zuffa that he didn't favor a drop to the 185-pound class. Although additional wins at 205 pounds would have only enhanced the Team Quest Temecula leader's pound-for-pound stock, his decision to fight at middleweight could produce one of the best fights of 2008 when he takes on "The Spider" Silva. A win could see him replace Silva atop the rankings.
6) Takanori Gomi (Pictures) (27-3, 1 no-decision)
For all his warts, "The Fireball Kid" is the most accomplished lightweight this young sport has seen. While Gomi's unrequited losses to Joachim Hansen (Pictures), B.J. Penn (Pictures) and Nick Diaz (Pictures) tend to stick out like a sore thumb, he has endured at the upper echelon of his division for seven years with heaps and heaps of top wins. Only time will tell whether the 29-year-old lightweight can continue to accrue those wins in his future home, wherever it is.
7) Shinya Aoki (Pictures) (12-2)
Aoki has solid wins in two weight classes that, at least for now, earn him a pound-for-pound ranking. As the sport trudges onward, though, it is imperative that the 24-year-old submission wizard gets back into action against top opposition. His return to MMA on New Year's Eve was tougher than expected. Fighting South Korean judo Olympic medalist Bu Kyung Jung (Pictures), who replaced Gesias Calvancante (Pictures) on a week's notice, Aoki was nearly submitted twice before finding his rhythm and pulling out a decision victory against the MMA newcomer.
8) Urijah Faber (Pictures) (20-1)
"The California Kid" needed a big win to gain the No. 1 spot at 145 pounds, and he did so with a decisive stoppage over veteran Jeff Curran (Pictures) in early December. That effort combined with his penchant for putting away opponents and an impressive overall record puts Faber, 28, in the Sherdog P4P for the first time. The featherweight buzzsaw will likely get a crack at former UFC lightweight champion Jens Pulver (Pictures) in his next WEC title defense.
9) Norifumi Yamamoto (Pictures) (17-1, 1 NC)
After establishing himself as a top featherweight, "KID" jumped to K-1 three years ago and moved up to lightweight for payday purposes. Along the way he happened to become a superstar in Japan, where he picked up some solid wins. Now, following his failed bid to qualify for the 2008 Beijing Games as a wrestler, Yamamoto is back in MMA. The 30-year-old fighter stopped Rani Yahya (Pictures) on New Year's Eve, showing once again how explosive he can be. Fighting at more natural weight now (near 135 pounds), Yamamoto could be a quick riser on this list if he is matched with quality opposition.
10) Randy Couture (Pictures) (16-8) It was a team effort for "The Natural" to fill the final spot. Couture's disciple Forrest Griffin (Pictures) completed the enormous task of knocking off high-standing pound-for-pounder Mauricio "Shogun" Rua in the Brazilian's UFC debut. As a result, Couture's two fantastic wins over Gabriel Gonzaga (Pictures) and Tim Sylvia (Pictures) in 2007 see him slide in the back door of the list. At the age of 44, Couture won't be able to climb the pound-for-pound ranks for long. However, the MMA icon could rocket up the ladder with an epic bout against Fedor Emelianenko (Pictures). His fighting status in limbo, though, Couture may never get that opportunity.
01-09-2008 03:23 PM
Not bad, but Gomi should not be on there. He lost to Diaz and went 1-1 with Aurelio (with the win being a close decision). He's been pretty inactive too. I think Sherk and maybe JZ belong on there for their performances lately but could understand the Sherk omission with the roid charges. I think Gonzaga, Machida, Fitch may be close to making it soon too.
01-09-2008 05:06 PM
Gonzaga? What the hell has he done? He beat CC and lost to Randy. Before that it was wins over mediocre opponents and an early loss to Werdum. He isn't even top 40 p4p. I do think he is very good, and has the potential, but as of right now........not appenin bruvv.
01-09-2008 05:17 PM
I said making it soon. A la when he beats Nog. Ooooo, you don't like that do you, buddy? But it's appenin'.
01-10-2008 08:09 PM
I think I might sense a little bit of hostility in this post. I'm pretty sure Gonzaga would beat Nog, but he has to do it first. Gonzaga can beat anyone, except Fedor of course, and maybe Barnett. If he fought Randy ten times, I would take Gonzaga 7 out of 10.
Originally Posted by jas123
01-10-2008 08:54 PM
I agree with the Randy comment. I don't remember when it happened, but it was definitely early: the accidental headbutt had everything to do with his subsequent performance. Randy might have won anyway, but we didn't get to see the fight as it would have played out in an ideal world without accidents.
Originally Posted by Alexander
01-10-2008 09:25 PM
Binging on Pure ****ing Rage
I'm surprised Faber was on there, he is great, and I guess being the best at 145lbs gives you that right, but somewhat ominous for me.
I would have put JZ and/or Shaolin on there instead of Gomi, however. Obviously the former before the latter as he ran through him in :35. Anybody think a rematch there would play out differently?
01-10-2008 11:43 PM
No hostility, just f-ing around. I thought we had done this before though, and you took Nog. That's why I threw in the "Ooooo,..." nonsense. I agree with your assessment.
Originally Posted by Alexander
Randy was really dominating in the clinch even before the takedown, but Gonzaga also caught him with 2 headkicks as I recall. I think eventually GG (not Alex) could maybe have KOed him if the nose break and bleeding wasn't a factor.
Similar Forum Threads
By Marcus ATW in forum Supplement Logs
Last Post: 10-10-2009, 07:57 AM
Last Post: 08-13-2007, 12:36 AM
By hardbody231981 in forum MMA
Last Post: 08-31-2006, 09:02 AM
By BingeAndPurge in forum Sports Talk
Last Post: 11-29-2005, 02:22 PM