I have been dating a heavier set female...

jamesf

New member
Awards
0
Guys.....I have been dating a heavier set female for the past 10 months and we are very happy. She is not ready to get fit so I do not pressure her. We love spending time together and love and respect one another. However, my guy friends always give me **** for dating a heavier set female. They always remind me that they look down on me for it and that I should be looking for something better b/c I work out and take good care of myself. I do not give in to their bs anymore b/c it really is lame. My buddy was giving me **** earlier today like "dude I wonder what the guys on the forum would think if they saw a pic of you and you girl" So I am asking to all of you honestly: Should I not be happy just because I am into fitness and she is not?
 
badbart

badbart

Registered User
Awards
1
  • Established
If you happy go for it. Looks don't last, its better to have a woman you enjoy then a sexy woman that ends up driving you crazy.
 
3clipseGT

3clipseGT

On my grind
Awards
4
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
Bro if she makes you happy thats all that matters. Happyness is in the eye of the beholder man. If ur bros/friends dont dig ur chick tell em to suck it up. While they may not be jealous of her looks im sure there jealous of how well she/you treat eachother, get along, etc.

Looks arent everything man and if ur happy, stay that way! :cheers:
 

B4n3 0n3

Guest
If you workout and have achieved a great body I don't think you should have to put up with a less than ideal womans body.
 

NO HYPE

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
"Guys.....I have been dating a heavier set female for the past 10 months and we are very happy."

"However, my guy friends always give me **** for dating a heavier set female."

....And you call them friends? :blink:
 
Rivet

Rivet

Registered User
Awards
1
  • Established
Guys.....I have been dating a heavier set female for the past 10 months and we are very happy. She is not ready to get fit so I do not pressure her.
Been there. Friends were saying similar things. That I could do better etc... OH well she cheated on me anyways with someone better suited (ugly) to her anyways. I was happy that he was scared of me however :)
 

B4n3 0n3

Guest
Been there. Friends were saying similar things. That I could do better etc... OH well she cheated on me anyways with someone better suited (ugly) to her anyways. I was happy that he was scared of me however :)
Sounds like a bad situation all around. Moral of the story make sure you match up well with your lady.
 
skull

skull

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
take this from an older guy whos been thru this, if shes not ready to get fit yet -she never will.staying fit is a matter of respect and pride.If you can deal with her being like that forever then its your choice.:donut:
 
Rodja

Rodja

Board Sponsor
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
I dated a girl that most would think was pudgy and I was definitely in love with her. I didnt care what my friends thought and they had enough respect to know that I chose to be her. Like it has been said before, it is MUCH better to be genuinely happy with someone than to just be infatuated with someone's physique.

Best of luck to you and if your friends still give you **** for your decision, then I don't think taht they are truly your "friends".
 
methusaleh

methusaleh

Board Supporter
Awards
1
  • Established
Amen to you for being mature enough to see beyond the appearance.

Looking back, I was the biggest jerk in high school, I literally would not even talk to a girl unless she was a perfect 10. I only dated a handful of girls because my standards were so high. Looking back at it, most of them were *****es, and if I had even lowered my standards to a girl who was a "9.5 out of 10", I would have found some very nice girls, and who knows...history could have been different.

Nowadays I admit I still want to date a girl who is pleasing to the eye, but personality matters so much more. My current girlfriend/fiance is the perfect woman for me, she is very good looking and actually goes to the gym more than I do, plus she can fix/ride/drive any motorcycle or car, shoot any gun, and enjoys everything I do. But she's no perfect 10, and I don't want her to be, I love her as she is!
 
BigCasino

BigCasino

Member
Awards
1
  • Established
Just do whatever makes you happy. I for one would not judge you negatively for it, and your friends shouldn't either. Just because you are hardcore into fitness and keeping in good shape does not mean that you need to be into bodybuilder chicks.

skinny model types, muscled, average, curvy, plus size, whatever everyone has their own preferences so don't worry about what yours is. Personally, I am quite fond of a Playboy bunny-esque look, but I would never say someone is less of a person because they have a couple extra pounds (I mean, we are not talking obese here right!?). Like you said, maybe her body is not in your normal preference range but you found something really appealing about her, and that's great! With all the stupid people running around out in the world be happy you found someone that can make you happy :)

If her not working out is going to bother you then you might want to soul search a bit harder, but if it will not bother you don't stress over her size.
 
somewhatgifted

somewhatgifted

Registered User
Awards
1
  • Established
Real friends accept your choices and should be happy of the fact that your happy. If they bring it up all the time its cause theyre jealous of your happiness that they havent been able to find with their chioce of women. I also believe that how you look can reflect who you are on the out side, theres a huge difference between a "heavy set girl" and a huge lazy slob. Genetics, thyroid and upbringing contribute largely to a females looks. Is it so wrong for a girl to go about life in a respectable manner hoping that there is a decent man out there who will love her for who she is. Afterall if you were in a terrible accident or had become ill, wouldnt you rather have a life long partner to care for you when your not looking good, or a vain, slim, drama queen wholl drop you when you dont meet her physical standards any more.
 
TINYTOAD

TINYTOAD

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
When you pick out a dog, for example, you pick out the one that's healthy and loves you. It shouldn't be any diffent when picking out a wife.

Stupid chivalry is bad. Don't try and fix anybody. Accept them for who they are. Don't stay with somebody defective, because you think that you're going to fix them. If you want a fat wife, who will develop health problems and die young, then okay. Otherwise, pick out the healthy one that loves you, and you'll be much happier in the long run. There are many fish in the sea. Don't box yourself in. I don't know of any old fat people. Do you?

-TT
 
skull

skull

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
this is all wrong, its about preservation of the fittest.athleats and workout types are a cut above the rest.if you stay with this chick her bad habbits will rub off on you--soon you will stop workin out and take up smokin--within a year you will be 300lbs.:donut:
 
skull

skull

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
When you pick out a dog, for example, you pick out the one that's healthy and loves you. It shouldn't be any diffent when picking out a wife.

Stupid chivalry is bad. Don't try and fix anybody. Accept them for who they are. Don't stay with somebody defective, because you think that you're going to fix them. If you want a fat wife, who will develop health problems and die young, then okay. Otherwise, pick out the healthy one that loves you, and you'll be much happier in the long run. There are many fish in the sea. Don't box yourself in. I don't know of any old fat people. Do you?

-TT
I agree with all except the dog part-- pick out the biggest meanest s.o.b. of the bunch
 
B5150

B5150

Legend
Awards
3
  • RockStar
  • Legend!
  • Established
One day in life you will have the humility to consider whether you are a REAL catch yourself. ;)

Love, respect, happiness, compatability are all internal things that you share regardless. Be who you are on the inside rather than what you appear to be on the outside. Don't give her a pitty relationship. If you truely feel like you guys are what you say for eachother. Cherish it. She may come around to fitness one day and you may not be as fit one day yourself.

If she means that much to you than stay with her. If her weight issues is really an issue TO YOU than move on. Your critical friends don't lie next to you on your bed looking you in the eye and tell you all their hopes and dreams and how much they missed you since the last time you were together. Intimacy and (com)passion does.

Don't mind me too much. I have a gorgeous, 18yo blonde, blue-eyed, cheerleader daughter away at her freshman year of college. I have another 5yo gorgeous, brown haired, brown eyed daughter who is in her freshman year of kindergarten. My greatest fear is what will be drawn to them is drawn to them by their appearance rather than their substance of character.
 

Jstrong20

Well-known member
Awards
3
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
  • RockStar
Of coarse your freinds are giving you sh!t. Thats what freinds do.lol. I don't know why you let it bother you though. Me and my freinds clown on each others girls all the time and its no big deal. I wouldn't care if a chick is thick if she is the one. Apperances are going to fade eventually anyway. It seems some people need to date the hottest girl they can have to boost their self esteem even if she is a complete *****.
 
TINYTOAD

TINYTOAD

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
I guess I'm not sure where you're coming from... Everybody is flawed. What's your conclusion: because I'm flawed, I should go out of my way to look for an equally flawed wife? My nephew just got divorced from a drug addicted wife, and I'm happy for him. I'm just sorry that he married her in the first place. He's a police officer, and her being arrested multiple times was a real embaresment for him. I guess when they got married, he felt sorry for her, and thought he could make her right. It just didn't work. Stupid chivalry.

Here are 10 stupid things men do to screw up their life....

Stupid Chivalry.
by getting involved with the wrong woman (weak, flakey, damaged, needy, desperate, stupid, untrustworthy, immature, etc.) you think that your love will save / transform her.

Stupid Independence.
Unwilling to admit "need" for bonding and intimacy, you hide in excess of work, play, drink, drugs, porn and meaningless sex.

Stupid Ambition.
Unable to comfortably and profoundly accept your inherent importance to society and family as husband and father, you bow to false idols of money, toys, power, and status.

Stupid Strength.
Uncomfortable with feeling weak, vunerable, uselses, powerless, or rejected, you use intimidation, force, or passive-agressiveness to regain control.

Stupid Sex.
Taking an attraction, opportunity, or erection as a "sign" you measure your masculinity and power by sexual conquests, infidelities, and orgasms.

Stupid Matrimony.
Lacking a mature sense of purpose, meaning, or value, of marriage, you realize too late you've gone down the aisle with the wrong woman for the wrong reason, and feel helpless to "fix it."

Stupid Husbanding.
Thinking that marriage is the honerable discharge from loving courtship, you continue to live as though you were single and your "mommy-wife" will take care of everything.

Stupid Parenting.
Believing that only women/mothers nurture children, you withdraw from hands-on parenting to assert your masculine importance, missing out on the true "soul food" of a child's hug.

Stupid Boyishness.
Having not yet worked out a comfortable emotional and social understanding with your mother, you form relationships with women that become geared to avenge, resolve, or protect you from your ties to Mommy.

Stupid Machismo.
Understanding the true and meaningful difference between being male and a man, you can become a man.

If you want details, go buy Dr. Laura's book. It's a good investment.

Pick out the healthy puppy, not the sick one.... You'll be much happier in the long run. You can't fix anybody... Don't even think that you can. If you're happy with what you have, fine, but don't think for a second, that you'll fix anybody.

-TT
 
Last edited:

Jstrong20

Well-known member
Awards
3
  • Established
  • First Up Vote
  • RockStar
I'm curious what some of you would do if your wife got disfigured in an accident. It sounds like alot of you would file a divorce on grounds of being unattractive.lol harsh!
 
TINYTOAD

TINYTOAD

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
I'm curious what some of you would do if your wife got disfigured in an accident. It sounds like alot of you would file a divorce on grounds of being unattractive.lol harsh!
Withold that whole 'until death do us part' thing... Have you no honor?

-TT
 

CallmeClark

Member
Awards
1
  • Established
I agree, fixer uppers may be easier to come by... But, they're not worth it. Go for the challenging one. Get the one that's not easy. Get the one that's worth chasing.
 

Zero Tolerance

Registered User
Awards
1
  • Established
You're hanging out with the wrong crowd.
 
skull

skull

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
theres a big difference between a woman who is vain and a woman who stays fit[takes good care of her self]sure looks fade but a healthy fit lifestyle shows disiplin and character and that carries on into other asspects of life.
 
jminis

jminis

Well-known member
Awards
1
  • Established
Bottom line here, be happy, the only reason you should ever bring her size up (again depending on what were talking about here) is for health reasons. Vanity is not a good reason.
 
Cuffs

Cuffs

Well-known member
Awards
1
  • Established
One good thing is that heavier chicks are more likely to do things in the sack that the fit ones won't...lol.

Dude, if she makes you happy, then you have found a good lady. Don't let your "friends" ruin what you have. It's hard enough to find that one that does it for you.
 
Big Matt

Big Matt

All The Whey Nutrition
Awards
1
  • Established
Guys.....I have been dating a heavier set female for the past 10 months and we are very happy. She is not ready to get fit so I do not pressure her. We love spending time together and love and respect one another. However, my guy friends always give me **** for dating a heavier set female. They always remind me that they look down on me for it and that I should be looking for something better b/c I work out and take good care of myself. I do not give in to their bs anymore b/c it really is lame. My buddy was giving me **** earlier today like "dude I wonder what the guys on the forum would think if they saw a pic of you and you girl" So I am asking to all of you honestly: Should I not be happy just because I am into fitness and she is not?

If you make each other happy then F what anybody else thinks! When it comes down to it, if you are not happy then everything else doesn't matter.

How does the old saying go?........."If your friends are dumping on your happiness....then are they truly your friends?"...something like that.....
 
moklepaul

moklepaul

Registered User
Awards
1
  • Established
Life's too short to live it for other people. Do what makes you happy. :)
 
Iron Warrior

Iron Warrior

Registered User
Awards
1
  • Established
All I gotta add is that you're only going to live once so live happy. If this girl makes you happy then stick with her, if you aren't fully satisfied then go look for other girls. If you live your life to please others then you'll never be happy because you can't make everyone happy no matter what you do.
 
spatch

spatch

Registered User
Awards
1
  • Established
If you want her to get in shape, tell her about the health benefits, not that she would be more attractive.
 

CallmeClark

Member
Awards
1
  • Established
Well yeah, that is a good point. Happiness is paramount.
 

wheystation

Board Sponsor
Awards
1
  • Established
I agree, fixer uppers may be easier to come by... But, they're not worth it. Go for the challenging one. Get the one that's not easy. Get the one that's worth chasing.

Did you actually just refer to a fellow human being as a "fixer upper"?
 

CallmeClark

Member
Awards
1
  • Established
Heh, maybe I did. lol But, I think that I was referring to that human being's situation moreso than the actual human being. But, in retrospect I can appreciate how it may be taken that way. Well, ya gotta like that. lol Double meanings by accident.
 
mp5man1

mp5man1

Registered User
Awards
0
As long as you are happy with her the way she is then stick with her and friends don't make fun of other friends wives and GF. We can make fun of the girls they pick up on but not the keepers.
 
Rivet

Rivet

Registered User
Awards
1
  • Established
friends don't make fun of other friends wives and GF. We can make fun of the girls they pick up on but not the keepers.
This is void during parties however and must be done to the persons face :drunk:
 

wheystation

Board Sponsor
Awards
1
  • Established
Okay - when you are 65 and your fat girlfriend is helping you to the bathroom or wiping your ass.......will it have mattered that she was heavy?

Will it matter that she gains weight when giving birth to your children? Will it matter when she looks into your eyes and vows to love you, no matter what?

I tell you what? Take the gamble - dump the fat chick and let's see if your judgemental friends will be there for you.......................

Love comes in all sizes and packages and when you find it - KEEP IT!!!!!!!!

Laura
 

ryano

Registered User
Awards
1
  • Established
Okay - when you are 65 and your fat girlfriend is helping you to the bathroom or wiping your ass.......will it have mattered that she was heavy?

Will it matter that she gains weight when giving birth to your children? Will it matter when she looks into your eyes and vows to love you, no matter what?

I tell you what? Take the gamble - dump the fat chick and let's see if your judgemental friends will be there for you.......................

Love comes in all sizes and packages and when you find it - KEEP IT!!!!!!!!

Laura
Good post Laura. I agree with you 100 percent. If your worried about her health then you should tell her how and why you FEEL that way. But love her as she is.
 
RoadBlocK

RoadBlocK

Well-known member
Awards
1
  • Established
You're hanging out with the wrong crowd.
I agree totally with Zero....

10 months together is different than a few dates, if your "friends" really talk bad about that person, when obviously something is working for you and her, then to me your "friends" are being disrespectful to you.

Just my 2cents, feel free to ignore it.
 
revodrew

revodrew

Registered User
Awards
1
  • Established
Just my thoughts:

If she is heavy where she is unhealthy then you really need to let her know this.

Basically just tell her that you are scared to get involved with a woman who shows great potential to have numerious health risks. If she isnt willing to get in shape so that you guys can have a long life together then maybe you are just to differant people.

If that is not the case and she is just a little thick but takes care of herself for the most part, then all is good.

Just remember when she gets pregnant, everything goes south!:hot:
 
skull

skull

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
think about all the hard work you do everyday to stay inshape.dont you think you deserve someone who shares the same philosophy?unless your a chuby chaser,then thats a whole different story:pizza:
 

wheystation

Board Sponsor
Awards
1
  • Established
think about all the hard work you do everyday to stay inshape.dont you think you deserve someone who shares the same philosophy?unless your a chuby chaser,then thats a whole different story:pizza:

That is all well and good and it is GREAT to meet someone who shares your common interests. But to rule out people based on what others say????!!!!!!! You are missing out on some pretty terrific people. And terrific people come in all shapes and sizes.

Part of me thinks that you have to be a parent to truly grasp the idea of unconditional love............... Or maybe just be a little older and wiser. I could not care less what people think about the physical appearance of those that I love. Because MY LOVE for them is not based on anything that superficial...........................

There is a lid for every pot out there!!!!!!
 
skull

skull

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
That is all well and good and it is GREAT to meet someone who shares your common interests. But to rule out people based on what others say????!!!!!!! You are missing out on some pretty terrific people. And terrific people come in all shapes and sizes.

Part of me thinks that you have to be a parent to truly grasp the idea of unconditional love............... Or maybe just be a little older and wiser. I could not care less what people think about the physical appearance of those that I love. Because MY LOVE for them is not based on anything that superficial...........................There is a lid for every pot out there!!!!!!
-------------dude your confusing 3 different issues here 1]Im not saying he should base anything on what his friends say 2]of course your going to love your kids unconditionaly 3]this fat girl could end up being his wife think about the unhealthy influence she could have on possible kids
There is a lid for every pot out there!!!!!![/QUOTE]
 
TINYTOAD

TINYTOAD

Active member
Awards
1
  • Established
Jamessf....

Why don't you post some pix, and put it to a vote?
You say 'hefty.' How fat are we talking here?

It's been my experience that women are at their best when you date them... Marry them, and it's all downhill from there. If they're fat now, and don't have a clue about proper nutrition or don't care, just think what you'll have on your hands in 5 years. You're not going to fix anybody. Don't give it a second thought... What you see is what you get. Don't expect anything more.

The point isn't 'If you're happy now.' The point is... will you be happy in 10 years, if things continue down this path. Don't do anything stupid to screw up you life. Lots of guys do, only to regret it in the future.

-TT-
 

Top