BILL O'REILLY, HOST: Now for the lead story tonight, two differing points of view.
Joining us now from Washington, David Bossie, president of the Citizens United, a conservative group. And from New York, Tony Smith, president of the French-American Foundation.
Mr. Smith, where am I going wrong here?
TONY SMITH, FRENCH-AMERICAN FOUNDATION: Well, I don't favor a boycott for three reasons. First of all -- excuse me -- it won't work. It won't be effective. It won't change French policy. Might even make the reprisals against us.
Secondly, with regard to Iraq, we're going to need Iraq. Sorry. We're going to need France in the short-term in Iraq. Not for the war, which we can handle by ourselves, but we're going to need all the support we can muster for the after war, the period of occupation.
We don't want to do that alone. We want our friends and allies with us to help us share the costs and to help us administer the occupation.
And the third and final reason is a more long-term one. France has been our ally for 200 years. It's in our best interest to maintain a continuous, close relationship with the French. They're the only country with which we've never fought a major war, and they've been with us in every major crisis during the Cold War period.
O'REILLY: Look, they're all logical reasons, and I can't -- I mean, I reject the French help after Saddam is removed. If I were President Bush, I wouldn't let the French near Iraq, all right? They're out of the equation. They're gone. They don't get any oil subsidies, they get nothing. All right?
But you say that they have been our friend and we're going to need them and all this. Over the last 40 years I have not seen much friendship on the part of France, and the Libya thing really struck home. You know, they wouldn't let us fly over their airspace to take reprisal against Gadhafi after he blew up that Berlin disco, targeting Americans and all of that.
How can you justify that, Mr. Smith? How can you justify that?
SMITH: There's a lot of cooperation going on right now...
O'REILLY: You're not answering my question, Mr. Smith. This is the no-spin zone. Libya, air space and France. How can you do it?
SMITH: I'm not here to defend French policy. I'm here to say that I think the boycott would be a bad idea.
O'REILLY: All right. You can't answer that question, sir, because it was a hostile act towards the United States.
Mr. Bossie, how do you see it?
You know, Bill, I have to agree with you completely. Look, this -- the French government needs to understand that actions have consequences, and by the American people speaking with their wallets and saying enough is enough, we can have a voice.
And we can tell the French and the Germans and anybody else through speaking with our wallets that this is the time that they need to pay very close attention to their economies because they're going to tank.
O'REILLY: All right. Now, Mr. Smith, you said that you don't think it will work. I submit to you, sir, that if a boycott of French goods in America takes place -- and I believe it will, believe me. I think most Americans see this for what it is. The French being anti-U.S.
Their economy is growing at a rate of 1 percent a year. If Americans cut back 50 percent buying French products, we put them into a recession, sir. Mr. Smith?
SMITH: Yes. Well, I think it would simply lead to reprisals.
O'REILLY: Like what? What kind of reprisals?
SMITH: They would retaliate against American goods.
O'REILLY: We don't need them.
SMITH: We export quite a few goods over there, as well. But beyond that, I think for the policy reasons, it's a bad idea. I have already explained what they are both with regard to Iraq and in the long-term.
O'REILLY: All right, Mr. Bossie, go ahead.
DAVID BOSSIE, PRESIDENT, CITIZENS UNITED: Look, we're not asking, at least Citizens United is not asking, for government intervention from the United States government. This is a people-to-people campaign. These are individuals all across the country, that I have never seen before, just stepping up and saying, "we're going to pour French wine down the gutter, we're going to bash a car. We're not going to, you know, not support these companies or these products."
And I've got to tell you, I've never seen just any -- at any time in American history -- and I've been paying close attention to this all through the '70s, '80s and '90s. And I've got to tell you, this is not something that's been seen before. The French are going to feel this, and they need to feel it.
O'REILLY: Now what did you say about the car, Mr. Bossie? Pour French wine, and I don't think I'd do that. If I had it, I'd just put it in the basement. But go ahead.
BOSSIE: There was an auto dealer in Nashville, Tennessee, that gave people a chance to destroy a brand new...
O'REILLY: I don't want to do any of that. Because I agree with Mr. Smith, I mean...
BOSSIE: No, no. It's a message. That's all...
O'REILLY: We want to send a message and we want to send it in a principled, disciplined way. We, Americans, are soldiers in a war on terror. Mr. Smith, you would agree with that, right? You would agree with that, wouldn't you?
SMITH: I would agree with that, and may I say also that there is an enormous amount of cooperation going on right now in the campaign against terrorism. The intelligence services and the police work cooperating between France and the United States has been very, very helpful.
O'REILLY: All right, and that's true. And I'm glad you pointed that out, because we want be fair.
But Mr. Smith, let me ask you this. Germany, Russia, and China are all against removing Saddam as well, mostly for economic reasons, but they want to see the USA weakened, as well. But they haven't sent emissaries to Africa, sir, to try to embarrass us. And that, to me, is over the line.
You can say, I don't believe a word Jacques Chirac says. I think he's a phony and he's playing to the home field crowd. But I may be wrong...
But when this guy sends his people down to Africa and says if you don't vote, OK, for the United States, because we'll reward you in economic ways. This is a hostile, then, act against the United States, sir, is it not?
SMITH: I don't defend French policy, and I think, in fact, they've gone too far with this. My position is that they will be important allies to us in the near-term.
O'REILLY: So you're appeasing them?
SMITH: No.
O'REILLY: Mr. Smith, yes, you are. You're not supporting them -- If you think their policy has gone too far and you're not supporting them, but you tell us not to do what we can, which means buy their products, you're appeasing them. You're letting them get away with it, Mr. Smith.
SMITH: No, I'm taking exactly the same position as George W. Bush, who said in his press conference that France is our ally and will continue to be so.
O'REILLY: Yes, but he also said if they veto, it will be considered, quote, "an unfriendly act," unquote.
Mr. Bossie, the last word on it. Go ahead.
BOSSIE: Look, the French have not been our ally since 1966, when they pulled out of the NATO integrated military structure, and they have not been our friends, and, Bill, you pointed out the 1980's throughout the Cold War they were up against Ronald Reagan every chance when he was trying to counter Soviet missile threats during the Libyan bombing fiasco, where it cost two American pilots' lives because of the French policy.
O'REILLY: Yes.
BOSSIE: So the French have not been our friends.
O'REILLY: It's time. It's time for the United States people, the American people, to say, "OK, France, you want to do this, then we do what we can."
Gentlemen, thank you very much. We appreciate it.
Joining us now from Washington, David Bossie, president of the Citizens United, a conservative group. And from New York, Tony Smith, president of the French-American Foundation.
Mr. Smith, where am I going wrong here?
TONY SMITH, FRENCH-AMERICAN FOUNDATION: Well, I don't favor a boycott for three reasons. First of all -- excuse me -- it won't work. It won't be effective. It won't change French policy. Might even make the reprisals against us.
Secondly, with regard to Iraq, we're going to need Iraq. Sorry. We're going to need France in the short-term in Iraq. Not for the war, which we can handle by ourselves, but we're going to need all the support we can muster for the after war, the period of occupation.
We don't want to do that alone. We want our friends and allies with us to help us share the costs and to help us administer the occupation.
And the third and final reason is a more long-term one. France has been our ally for 200 years. It's in our best interest to maintain a continuous, close relationship with the French. They're the only country with which we've never fought a major war, and they've been with us in every major crisis during the Cold War period.
O'REILLY: Look, they're all logical reasons, and I can't -- I mean, I reject the French help after Saddam is removed. If I were President Bush, I wouldn't let the French near Iraq, all right? They're out of the equation. They're gone. They don't get any oil subsidies, they get nothing. All right?
But you say that they have been our friend and we're going to need them and all this. Over the last 40 years I have not seen much friendship on the part of France, and the Libya thing really struck home. You know, they wouldn't let us fly over their airspace to take reprisal against Gadhafi after he blew up that Berlin disco, targeting Americans and all of that.
How can you justify that, Mr. Smith? How can you justify that?
SMITH: There's a lot of cooperation going on right now...
O'REILLY: You're not answering my question, Mr. Smith. This is the no-spin zone. Libya, air space and France. How can you do it?
SMITH: I'm not here to defend French policy. I'm here to say that I think the boycott would be a bad idea.
O'REILLY: All right. You can't answer that question, sir, because it was a hostile act towards the United States.
Mr. Bossie, how do you see it?
You know, Bill, I have to agree with you completely. Look, this -- the French government needs to understand that actions have consequences, and by the American people speaking with their wallets and saying enough is enough, we can have a voice.
And we can tell the French and the Germans and anybody else through speaking with our wallets that this is the time that they need to pay very close attention to their economies because they're going to tank.
O'REILLY: All right. Now, Mr. Smith, you said that you don't think it will work. I submit to you, sir, that if a boycott of French goods in America takes place -- and I believe it will, believe me. I think most Americans see this for what it is. The French being anti-U.S.
Their economy is growing at a rate of 1 percent a year. If Americans cut back 50 percent buying French products, we put them into a recession, sir. Mr. Smith?
SMITH: Yes. Well, I think it would simply lead to reprisals.
O'REILLY: Like what? What kind of reprisals?
SMITH: They would retaliate against American goods.
O'REILLY: We don't need them.
SMITH: We export quite a few goods over there, as well. But beyond that, I think for the policy reasons, it's a bad idea. I have already explained what they are both with regard to Iraq and in the long-term.
O'REILLY: All right, Mr. Bossie, go ahead.
DAVID BOSSIE, PRESIDENT, CITIZENS UNITED: Look, we're not asking, at least Citizens United is not asking, for government intervention from the United States government. This is a people-to-people campaign. These are individuals all across the country, that I have never seen before, just stepping up and saying, "we're going to pour French wine down the gutter, we're going to bash a car. We're not going to, you know, not support these companies or these products."
And I've got to tell you, I've never seen just any -- at any time in American history -- and I've been paying close attention to this all through the '70s, '80s and '90s. And I've got to tell you, this is not something that's been seen before. The French are going to feel this, and they need to feel it.
O'REILLY: Now what did you say about the car, Mr. Bossie? Pour French wine, and I don't think I'd do that. If I had it, I'd just put it in the basement. But go ahead.
BOSSIE: There was an auto dealer in Nashville, Tennessee, that gave people a chance to destroy a brand new...
O'REILLY: I don't want to do any of that. Because I agree with Mr. Smith, I mean...
BOSSIE: No, no. It's a message. That's all...
O'REILLY: We want to send a message and we want to send it in a principled, disciplined way. We, Americans, are soldiers in a war on terror. Mr. Smith, you would agree with that, right? You would agree with that, wouldn't you?
SMITH: I would agree with that, and may I say also that there is an enormous amount of cooperation going on right now in the campaign against terrorism. The intelligence services and the police work cooperating between France and the United States has been very, very helpful.
O'REILLY: All right, and that's true. And I'm glad you pointed that out, because we want be fair.
But Mr. Smith, let me ask you this. Germany, Russia, and China are all against removing Saddam as well, mostly for economic reasons, but they want to see the USA weakened, as well. But they haven't sent emissaries to Africa, sir, to try to embarrass us. And that, to me, is over the line.
You can say, I don't believe a word Jacques Chirac says. I think he's a phony and he's playing to the home field crowd. But I may be wrong...
But when this guy sends his people down to Africa and says if you don't vote, OK, for the United States, because we'll reward you in economic ways. This is a hostile, then, act against the United States, sir, is it not?
SMITH: I don't defend French policy, and I think, in fact, they've gone too far with this. My position is that they will be important allies to us in the near-term.
O'REILLY: So you're appeasing them?
SMITH: No.
O'REILLY: Mr. Smith, yes, you are. You're not supporting them -- If you think their policy has gone too far and you're not supporting them, but you tell us not to do what we can, which means buy their products, you're appeasing them. You're letting them get away with it, Mr. Smith.
SMITH: No, I'm taking exactly the same position as George W. Bush, who said in his press conference that France is our ally and will continue to be so.
O'REILLY: Yes, but he also said if they veto, it will be considered, quote, "an unfriendly act," unquote.
Mr. Bossie, the last word on it. Go ahead.
BOSSIE: Look, the French have not been our ally since 1966, when they pulled out of the NATO integrated military structure, and they have not been our friends, and, Bill, you pointed out the 1980's throughout the Cold War they were up against Ronald Reagan every chance when he was trying to counter Soviet missile threats during the Libyan bombing fiasco, where it cost two American pilots' lives because of the French policy.
O'REILLY: Yes.
BOSSIE: So the French have not been our friends.
O'REILLY: It's time. It's time for the United States people, the American people, to say, "OK, France, you want to do this, then we do what we can."
Gentlemen, thank you very much. We appreciate it.